Keep it simple is what I'd like to do.

I need to remove a great deal of superfluous code. (i.e. tables)

I tried it a couple of years ago, but there was such a wide range of visitors using low-res monitors that the site wouldn't work (for those users).

If I can see 'who is using what', then I can fix a width and the site will load much faster. (I am aware that a fluid css design works just as well, but with so much content on display, I think it better to go with the fixed width option.)