Thanks for the link, Lee. I didn't find any answers (to my questions) there ... but never mind.

Why do companies pay? Legislation, I should imagine. And, anyway, who does pay? In many (most?) cases I suspect it is one of the usual sources (that is, the "man in the street", the consumer, the rail passenger, the taxpayer et al).

I don't know who Fabrice Muamba is ... but I wonder when those "public-access defibs" were last looked at (by the "user"). And that's the trouble with the whole concept, I would have thought. Just who is responsible for them ... the passer-by? In short:- who is the "user"?

And (whilst I'm on), surely the real problem with them is ... well they don't just jump off the wall and apply themselves, do they? What if the passer-by just (for whatever reason - including fear of litigation, I should imagine) carries on passing-by? OK, I'm an old-fashioned guy, but I'm trying to find ways of avoiding the word "scam" (or, if you prefer, "racket") here.

How about settling for:- "a false sense of security"? think

Yes, I realise you are talking about testing. And I'm not against any biomed trying to earn an honest crust, believe me. smile