I believe there's a 6-month service-exchange on tyco SpO2 accessories - if the batch number is quoted they can give the date of manufacture, etc. If you're unhappy with your probes or interface cables then I guess they can be returned to Tyco for assessment, thus exchange if they've failed prematurely. I guess there's always going to be the argument whether there's been abuse, etc but it's worth a try if large numbers of relatively new probes are involved, perhaps.
We've had very similar problems, in the past, with the Nellcor compatible Welch Allyn VSM (we had 70 of these) using DEC-8 and DS100A Oximax probes. 3 scenarios - Older Welch Allyn VSM that were apparently r-cal compatible only (grey probes only) yet woudn't work with Oximax probes (that should be r-cal compatible), a mixture of those that may or may not have worked with both Oximax/r-cal (blue) and r-cal (grey) probes depending upon when they were manufactured it seemed (irrepsective of the fact they were r-cal compatible, i.e. older SpO2 PCBs), and newer Welch Allyns that only worked with Oximax/r-cal (blue) probes (obviously, following Jonathans comments, since they only support Oximax it seems).
We really suffered at the time when Oximax probes were being introduced a few years back - it took a while to weed out the problems. Operators were actually mixing Oximax and non-Oximax DS-100s and DEC-8s. However we had OEM SpO2 boards replaced under warranty. I'm not convinced that Oximax probes are reliable when used on Welch Allyn r-cal (1st generation) Nellcor OEM SpO2 even though they're meant to be r-cal compatible. Also I think there are other underlying issues with poor connections on the VSM SpO2 interconnects.
Nellcor state that Oximax probes are r-cal/Oximax compatible. If the SpO2 monitor is 1st generation the r-cal function will be used but there will be no motion tolerance (Oximax digital features). If the SpO2 monitor supports Oximax then r-cal is not used - calibration data is provided to the monitor, by the probe, digitally. The oximax motion tolerant performance relies on the digital functions built into the Oximax probes but r-cal should still work on older, 1st generation, SpO2 monitors.