OK so who's going to make John a cake with a file in it ?
Seriously, I've read the messages posted here and I became concerned about the confused knowledge of risk management that exists.
Take this scenario - you decide to deviate from the manufacturers recommended PPM interval an infusion device. It fails. The patient affected does not die but his length of stay in hospital is increased because his treatment did not take effect and he has sustained some long term damage.
No corpse here so no coroner. But his family complain and decide to sue the Trust for negligence.
The court must prove that a duty of care was breached. You would have to provide details that this medical device was being managed in accordance with the Controls Assurance standard. Service records would be requested and the manufacturers operating manual which would recomend the service interval. It would clearly be seen that you had deviated from the manufacturers advice. Why ?
You can put your case forward but the prosecution would call an expert witness who would claim that your judgement was wrong. Similarly they could call the manufacturer who would provide a reasoned argument for setting the service interval.
The outcome would most likely be that the Trust had breached its duty of care and would have to pay up - moderate damages, say £50 - 200K depending on the severity of the patients condition.
Had he died that's a whole new ball game! Forget the coroner - all he does is decide the manner in which he died.
The family would go through all of the above - hefty damages maybe even £ms.
But you were also the "professional" person who caused this. The family could then sue you in much the same way as they would sue the surgeon who cuts off the wrong finger. Hope you have loads of money!
The Trust's internal enquiry will finger you as the one who made the decision putting the whole Trust and every patient at risk - suspension, investigation, dismissal?
Not good on your CV, you'll be lucky to get another job (when you are released - see below)
And then along comes the Health and Safety Executive! This is where the (mis)conception that its the Chief Exec who carries the can. Yes the CEO has the ultimate responsibility and may get fined.
If the Trust had ratified your decision this could be a corporate killing. But you made this decision individually so you carry the can. Remember the HASWA 1974 under which you have a duty to safeguard the health and safety of yourself and others. Well you didn't did you? You took a risk with no authority, no endorsement by the Trust Board and it will be you needing the cake with the file in it. Good luck.
The advice given in this message is without prejudice and is not a legal opinion and carries no legal undertaking. An such issues should be examined by a qualified legal practitioner on an individual case basis.