Home Articles Downloads Forum Products Services EBME Expo Contact ☰
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate Thread
Page 3 of 9 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 3
Newbie
Offline
Newbie
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 3
OK so who's going to make John a cake with a file in it ? rolleyes
Seriously, I've read the messages posted here and I became concerned about the confused knowledge of risk management that exists.

Take this scenario - you decide to deviate from the manufacturers recommended PPM interval an infusion device. It fails. The patient affected does not die but his length of stay in hospital is increased because his treatment did not take effect and he has sustained some long term damage.
No corpse here so no coroner. But his family complain and decide to sue the Trust for negligence.
The court must prove that a duty of care was breached. You would have to provide details that this medical device was being managed in accordance with the Controls Assurance standard. Service records would be requested and the manufacturers operating manual which would recomend the service interval. It would clearly be seen that you had deviated from the manufacturers advice. Why ?
You can put your case forward but the prosecution would call an expert witness who would claim that your judgement was wrong. Similarly they could call the manufacturer who would provide a reasoned argument for setting the service interval.

The outcome would most likely be that the Trust had breached its duty of care and would have to pay up - moderate damages, say £50 - 200K depending on the severity of the patients condition.

Had he died that's a whole new ball game! Forget the coroner - all he does is decide the manner in which he died.
The family would go through all of the above - hefty damages maybe even £ms.
But you were also the "professional" person who caused this. The family could then sue you in much the same way as they would sue the surgeon who cuts off the wrong finger. Hope you have loads of money!
The Trust's internal enquiry will finger you as the one who made the decision putting the whole Trust and every patient at risk - suspension, investigation, dismissal?
Not good on your CV, you'll be lucky to get another job (when you are released - see below)

And then along comes the Health and Safety Executive! This is where the (mis)conception that its the Chief Exec who carries the can. Yes the CEO has the ultimate responsibility and may get fined.
If the Trust had ratified your decision this could be a corporate killing. But you made this decision individually so you carry the can. Remember the HASWA 1974 under which you have a duty to safeguard the health and safety of yourself and others. Well you didn't did you? You took a risk with no authority, no endorsement by the Trust Board and it will be you needing the cake with the file in it. Good luck.

The advice given in this message is without prejudice and is not a legal opinion and carries no legal undertaking. An such issues should be examined by a qualified legal practitioner on an individual case basis.

Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 380
Sage
Offline
Sage
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 380
Pamie, I fully agree

Joined: May 2001
Posts: 457
Sage
Offline
Sage
Joined: May 2001
Posts: 457
Absolutely Spot On Pamie

As I previously posted I guess the Ex-Pat Rules were,nt off the mark at all ie

Cover Your Ar**

Keep Laughing

Take the Money !!! Regards to all T. laugh

Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 797
Likes: 1
KM Offline
Philosopher
Offline
Philosopher
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 797
Likes: 1
QUESTION IS, WITH ALL THIS OPINION. DOES JOHN STILL FEEL HES MADE THE RIGHT DECISION ?

Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 391
Sage
Offline
Sage
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 391
Here's a thought I just had whilst contemplating hangin' meself after reading all of the above.

What we are saying is that if we use all our expertise and professional judgement to lengthen a period of routine maintenance and there is an incident then we are liable and will be thrown to the wolves.

From other peoples postings it seems that the majority decision is that no matter what steps you take and how well you document you are still up sh** creek without a paddle.

If then, using the same logic, you follow to the letter the OEM guidance or even have the company do the maintenance and there is an incident imbetween services that can be put down to equipment failure does that then mean the OEM is sued in court, using the same scenarios as applied above.

I know this happens occasionally, but not to the level I think I'm interpreting here.

Every time a piece of equipment fails, whether there is a fatality or not, does that mean we can sue the OEM for a "potential life threatening incident"


Why worry, Be happy!
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 3
Newbie
Offline
Newbie
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 3
Obviously equipment fails between services on some occasions, these things happen. Provided you have followed procedures and done everything reasonably practicable (HASWA)to prevent it happening then you're not going to get thrown to the wolves. But in order to cover yourself if there is a piece of guidance follow it.

If you're not sure about something consult your superiors. Once you have passed the problem on you have effectively passed the liability to that person.

As you paddle up that creek beware of the alligator swimming alongside. wink

Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 1,969
Likes: 32
Hero
OP Offline
Hero
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 1,969
Likes: 32
Bioman,
No disrespect to the MHRA, but they sit on the fence when it comes to maintenence.
There are certain devices, i.e. gas regulators that do require service exchange.
(Although we are switching to bottles with built in regulators. i.e. no headache finding regulators.)

Some high risk device will always be maintained 'by the book' . Some lower risk devices will not. I see it as my job that this is not left to chance, but we have a strategy for using our skills appropriately, and decide what we will maintain less often , or not maintain .

KM, Tony, Bill, Pamie,
I have worked at, and visited many depts that over-maintain, or don't maintain. The reality is that both scenarios are wrong.

I'll keep doing it in this way because I don't have the resources to do it any other way. Given this scenario (and a forecast of equipment assets doubling in 10 yrs) I think you must take a risk based approach - Is it not safer to manage the risk, rather than making excuses that we do not haves the resources to do the job properly? confused

As a manager, I make my decisions based on evidence and experience. Incidents normally occur through missuse, not negligent maintenance. frown

Darren, Robert
Sounds like you're in my corner. NASA use RCM (reliability centred maintenance), as do all leading large corporations. The NHS is the biggest corporation in the world. Isn't it about time we stopped pussyfooting around and come up with realistic strategic maintenance planning?? mad ECRI have recognised that healthcare organisations will benefit from RCM.


Be Proactive and reactive.
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 160
Mentor
Offline
Mentor
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 160
Does anybody believe that all manufacturer's follow all the procedures in their own manuals?

Doesn't it seem odd that kit requires service every 12/12 exactly? How do they design this need in? If this period is in fact arbitary, and was specified during design before anyone had used the kit out there, might we not be in a better position to judge, with hind-sight, than the designer?

Car manufacturers are extending periods all the time, better design, better materials, etc. Why is this not happening to medical kit? Maybe it's cos consumers chose to purchase cars with lower service costs. Is kit ever advertised as "requiring less service"?

Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 117
Savant
Offline
Savant
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 117
Grahame, Have sent you a reply in your EBME private mail box. My box indicates that you have not had a visit to your box lately. Pls let me know if it did not arrive and I will re-sendit. Cheers

Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 2,020
Hero
Offline
Hero
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 2,020
Dear All,
I had hoped my previous email would provoke more of a debate.
I had taken advice from a couple of health and safety professionals who agree that we might well be on sticky ground leagally if we do not follow the manufacturers recommendations without proper assessment of the situation. And any lawyer will find any assessment we might do full of holes, after all that is their job.
But surely the point is that medical engineering is our job, we do know what we are doing and are professionals in our field as well, more so than any lawyer. The manufacturers recommendations are just that "recommendations", they cannot leagally dictate to us once we own the equipment.
The health and safety at work act and the PUWE regulations are full of "reasonably practicable" and similar statements, and tell you to assess each situation.
Are we automaton that follow rigidly or professional engineers with a mind, experience and knowledge who can make reasoned decissions? If the former why employ us at all?
The crunch comes when no-one will back us up.
The MHRA seem to not want to make a statement but hide behind the manufacturers and we all know about buck passing in hospitals and ranks that rapidly close.
My point was that medicine is going down the route of assessed, reasoned, or reliability based decission making, (however you name it) as is a lot of the engineering world, and as has been pointed out, the maintenance intervals of most technical equipment is far higher than it used to be because of good modern engineering.
Why are we not following suit? Is it purely through fear of personal litigation?
Until I know that I will be listened to as a knowledgable professional that I thought I was employed to be,I too am covering my a**e.
Remeber that the assessment should be continually monitored and if you push the serice interval too far you should pick that up and correct for it so it should be safe in the long run.
Robert

PS. I presume we are talking about quantity of work done as well as intervals. How much of a PPM on modern equipment is maintenance and part replacement, and how much is check the thing works correctly?

As a matter of interest has anyone had to go to court to defend their maintenance or are we affraid of ghosts that might exist in our imagination? Just curious.


My spelling is not bad. I am typing this on a Medigenic keyboard and I blame that for all my typos.
Page 3 of 9 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Moderated by  DaveC in Oz, RoJo 

Link Copied to Clipboard
Who's Online Now
1 members (daisizhou), 22,850 guests, and 88 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Newest Members
Pip Fox, Engzaki, MacMc, AraEmin, Edouardohaag
10,395 Registered Users
Forum Statistics
Forums26
Topics11,288
Posts74,594
Members10,395
Most Online69,877
Jul 17th, 2026
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5