|
|
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303 Likes: 17
Master
|
OP
Master
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303 Likes: 17 |
Just a warning to all those who think a device has failed the protective earth resistance test, it may not have failed but contain an inductor in the earth connection!
Many commonly used test instruments on the market, even new units, that use an AC source for the test current can give incorrect readings when an inductor is present in the earth connection (as used for EMC). This is a known issue with many Fluke Biomed meters as well as the Rigel 266. Those meters that use a DC test current, such as the Rigel 288 and GMC Secutest SIII, do not exhibit this problem.
One solution is to try a different test current, if available, on the tester to see if a lower reading is obtained. This lower reading is most likely the correct value and not the higher or failed value!
It should be noted that this problem is not related to overcoming contact oxidisation and is purely a error in the meters measuring circuit when an inductor is present in the earth connection.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 2,020
Hero
|
Hero
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 2,020 |
If this inductor gives a high reading for a test does that not indicate that in the real world the earth impedance will also be high and therefore not effective? I am assuming that when you say it uses a.c. for the test it is at 50Hz. Obviously it is a different matter if it is an h.f. signal and the inductor has negligeable effect at 50Hz. RoJo
My spelling is not bad. I am typing this on a Medigenic keyboard and I blame that for all my typos.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 362 Likes: 3
Sage
|
Sage
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 362 Likes: 3 |
Many commonly used test instruments on the market, even new units, that use an AC source for the test current can give incorrect readings when an inductor is present in the earth connection (as used for EMC). This is a known issue with many Fluke Biomed meters as well as the Rigel 266. News to me! Earth bonding , this is a low impedance path to earth to prevent hazardous voltages appearing on the equipment. Protective Earth Conductor , conductor to be connected between the protective earth terminal and an external protective earthing system. Protective Earth Terminal , connected to conductive parts of Class I equipment for safety purposes. This terminal is intended to be connected to an external earthing system by a protective earth conductor. Potential Equalization Conductor , conductor providing a connection between equipment and the potential equalization busbar of the electrical installation (involves joining together metalwork that is or may be earthed so that it is at the same voltage). In IEC60601, the test is conducted using a 50Hz current between 10A and 25A for a period of at least 5 seconds with a no load voltage not exceeding 6V, when testing the impedance of a protective earth. Those meters that use a DC test current, such as the Rigel 288 and GMC Secutest SIII, do not exhibit this problem. Can you provide some evidence that these tester's use a DC Test current? An inductor will have a negligible effect on PE readings at 50 Hz, what you are observing is related to the higher current levels overcoming contact oxidisation and providing a lower impedance measurement.
Last edited by Sean Fearon; 30/03/11 11:36 AM.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 601
Philosopher
|
Philosopher
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 601 |
Are these inductors in-line? If so what values are they? I would imagine that they would be quite low to remduce RF noise and as such shouldn't have much effect at 50Hz.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 362 Likes: 3
Sage
|
Sage
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 362 Likes: 3 |
As I thought, the Rigel 288 & GMC Secutest SIII are not compliant with IEC60601 requirements for protective earth measurements. (They use a DC 200mA system). http://www.rigelmedical.com/downloads/0008-Tests-available-on-Rigel288.pdfCould this be that Mike is trying to raise the profile of IEC 62353 standard, via an alternative route (as per his previous posts?). The IEC 62353 standard has not been universally adopted, and has been extensively discussed on this forum previously.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 14,815 Likes: 72
Super Hero
|
Super Hero
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 14,815 Likes: 72 |
If the protective conductor earth continuity test "fails", then it fails, whatever the reason, I would have thought. Inductors in the earth lead? Whatever for? There shouldn't be enough (leakage) current there to generate any sort of interference, unless something is seriously wrong anyway! Erroneous readings at 50 Hz? Surely testing at mains frequency is the only valid method? That's what the kit gets plugged in to, after all. 
If you don't inspect ... don't expect.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303 Likes: 17
Master
|
OP
Master
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303 Likes: 17 |
I can confirm inductors in the earth are allowed and do exist in some equipment!
The manufacturers of the test equipment know about this problem and have confirmed the problem to me directly!
It has nothing to do with IEC 62353! It will affect any earth test as these are the same no matter what the standard (only the current and possibly the use of AC or DC is different).
The effect is due to errors in the meter and is not because the equipment under test is faulty!
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 362 Likes: 3
Sage
|
Sage
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 362 Likes: 3 |
Worked repairing Biotek / Fluke Biomedical 601Pro's for Fluke UK Agents in their service department for a number of years on and off. Don’t remember any technical service communication highlighting such an issue. The effect is due to errors in the meter Spill the beans, explain and indicate which manufacturer (or Sales Rep) told you this? One solution is to try a different test current, if available, on the tester to see if a lower reading is obtained. This lower reading is most likely the correct value and not the higher or failed value! Can you explain how using a different test current resolves this issue? (As the manufacturers of the test equipment know, and have confirmed the problem with you). Are you sure that you’re asserting that the manufacturers are aware of errors in the measuring circuit, and have failed to pass this on to the Customers? (I foresee some interesting communications over this issue).
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303 Likes: 17
Master
|
OP
Master
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303 Likes: 17 |
Only some meters exhibit this problem and in most systems there will be no inductor fitted in the earth so no mater what meter is used all readings will be normal.
This issue has only recently been brought to the manufacturers attention due to the use of filter inductors in the PE connection of devices (the Acuson X300 springs to mind). Some products, that use an AC test current, do not have any problem but others do and often depends on the test current used as the problem is related to the source impedance of the test current.
I have had this problem confirmed by Fluke Biomed in the USA. I don't think the problem is widely advertised as it affects only a few medical products on the market but may increase as the EMC requirements become tighter.
But what this shows is you should not always rely on any test meter as being 100% reliable and accurate! And therefore the fault may not always be in the item you test!
With respect to the test current used when conducting PE resistance measurements it is best practice to use the lowest current possible to prevent damage to equipment that is 'in service'. Historically the value of 1A has been widely used.
With advent of IEC 62353 and the guidance in DB2006(05) the use of IEC 60601-1 type tests is no longer recommended. In terms of best practice IEC 62353 is the only choice and in these current economic times the simplified tests ensure minimum costs with maximum safety. I don't mind admitting I am a proponent of IEC 62353 but this was borne out of researching the standard thoroughly to ensure I could be confident in its effectiveness as a replacement for selective type tests.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 362 Likes: 3
Sage
|
Sage
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 362 Likes: 3 |
I will ask for some feedback from Ultramedic on this one regarding Fluke Biomedical USA assertion of meter circuit errors, which the likelihood of occurring (by your confirmation) is minimal.
It does not really show us anything, (as no one seriously believes that test equipment is 100% accurate or reliable anyway), most users routinely use proving units to confirm that their test equipment is performing within manufacturers specifications in between calibrations, and are aware of errors within published tolerance values. If you’re not, you shouldn’t be using test equipment.
Most competent users of safety testers checking to IEC60101 will find that the available 1A, 10 & 25A Earth bonding type tests on existing testers are quite adequate and have never caused damage.
I personally disagree; complying with best practice does not make IEC 62353 the only choice at all. DB 2006(05) is guidance only. Any conscientious Biomed when faced with two standards for Electrical Safety of Medical Equipment would utilise the higher standard for tests, as opposed to simplified tests.
In the current economic climate, I would select the lower current selection options available for PE measurement in an IEC60101 tester, and thus save the Trust & the Taxpayer the cost of buying a new safety tester that has the IEC 62353 option installed. We are all accountable for public monies.
The argument that simplified tests ensure minimum costs and maximum safety sounds like a sales pitch, but I could not justify the expense, when perfectly good existing electrical safety testing equipment is available , and can be utilised. I can be confident that I am complying with my Trusts Standing Financial Instructions, (not to waste money).
|
|
|
|
1 members (daisizhou),
26,081
guests, and
100
robots. |
|
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
|
Forums26
Topics11,288
Posts74,594
Members10,395
| |
Most Online69,877 Jul 17th, 2026
|
|
|
|