Hi John,
Thanks for that if I need anything clarifying RE: standards, etc, I'll get in touch.
The point of my postings, from a lay-persons perspective RE: continuity testing, fundamental design limitations, etc, and as an engineer maintaining medical equipment, is not to infer any problems with the calibration of specific devices or how well they compare but has been to outline the potential problems with low-current testing performance generally - nevermind contact problems and physical issues in the DUT.
Also it's to comment that my colleagues and myself are probably going to be stuck in the difficult position of intuitively being aware of and of physically observing problems but may be obliged to follow guidelines (DB6801 supp1), recommendations (IPEM), upcoming standards (62353), that may push us towards test regimens (1A or less) using instrumentation and techniques that some feel may not be up to what's required for earth bond testing and that many will feel uncomfortable with.
There are certainly disadvantages, RE:accuracy and repeatability of earth bond resistance measurements, taken by safety testers in current usage when testing at 1A or less, that need to be weighed up against the likelihood of damage to a DUT - which is rare in my experience of maintaning medical equipment, although I have experienced a couple of problems that I've attributed to 25A testing.
However when routine safety testing, in volume, the last thing I'd want to be doing is routinely trying to sift out the incidences of bad connections, between the DUT and the tester, from potentially faulty earths - especially not if I know, from years of experience, a device can tolerate 10A or more, routinely, without the connection problems that may be observed at lower currents.
I hope, if you read my earlier postings, you noticed that I conciously quoted "worst-case" prior to all my comments concerning accuracy and resolution (although resolution is likely to be an irreducible effect RE: calibration, eh?). I'm aware that calibrated intruments used at higher currents are likely to meet the +/-10% requirement after calibration and should not pose any problems in use when used at currents significantly greater than 1A.
However, as you've inferred yourself, John, it may be very difficult, if not impossible, for some testers in widespread use, currently, to meet the +/-10% using 1A test current or less. This has consistently been my argument in earlier postings.
In future, if I'm put into a position where I'm required to test at 1A or less and record the results, I'd like my continuity test to be able to give me an accurate figure for resistance (thus be able to accurately resolve to at least 3 sig figs between 0.00Ohm and O.30Ohm) that's repeatable - especially if I'm going to stand there fiddling with a mains cable looking for small changes in earth resistance that might indicate a dodgy earth!
Otherwise we may just as well have a Go/No-Go type of test indication that, besides not giving any clues or feedback to what's happening if there's a problem, in my opinion, can lead to ignorance of what's being measured and complacency on the part of those doing the test.
I hope that when IPEM publish their guidance notes on safety testing and IEC their 62353 standard that they include rationales that are meaningful and intended to educate those who carry out safety testing rather than expecting them to just take it at face value. Shame we'll have to pay for the privilege though.
Cheers.