Home Articles Downloads Forum Products Services EBME Expo Contact ☰
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate Thread
Page 3 of 5 1 2 3 4 5
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 14,815
Likes: 72
Super Hero
Offline
Super Hero
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 14,815
Likes: 72

What RCD(s) are you talking about there, then, John?

You may not find them in some (many?) parts of the world, after all. frown

Or was that intended as joke (as I have just been reminded what day it is)?

Originally Posted By: JB
Progress is all about doing more with less

Yes, I can't afford the prices talked about for your test kit, either. So I definitely have to follow Mies' Maxim*. whistle

* "Less is More", for those who don't know it.


If you don't inspect ... don't expect.
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 2,020
Hero
Offline
Hero
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 2,020
RCD? laugh
In some places we do not even have an earth due to rusty metal conduit trunking.... Yes on the wards!!!! shocked
RoJo

In an NHS hospital not the third world too


My spelling is not bad. I am typing this on a Medigenic keyboard and I blame that for all my typos.
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 14,815
Likes: 72
Super Hero
Offline
Super Hero
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 14,815
Likes: 72

Do I spot an oxymoron? smile

Meanwhile, could it be that the 200 mA test current is being promoted simply to push the idea (nice as it may be) of a hand-held electrical safety tester?

How does such an instrument get on with insulation testing, I wonder? think


If you don't inspect ... don't expect.
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303
Likes: 17
MikeX Offline OP
Master
OP Offline
Master
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303
Likes: 17
Electricians have been using a test current of 200mA for many years now and probably perform more tests than we do with medical equipment. They have never felt the need to resort to an arc welder to test the safety of their work! I don't think there has been a flood of people receiving an electric shock as a result of the low current used.

@RoJo - If you don't have a good earth, due to rusty conduit, then an RCD will provide you with protection. They work on a differential principle so any imbalance in current will trip them.

IEC60364-7-710 calls for either an IT supply or RCD for use in medical locations so is valid for almost all the world.

The test current debate for PE testing is long running but normally the use of a low current is safer than using a high current. But in all cases there is no benefit in using more than 10A. A failure at 200mA can normally be removed by simply un-plugging and re-inserting the IEC lead so is no big deal as this is a better way of removing the oxidisation than welding the contacts with 25A! In fact there is a good chance it indicates a new IEC lead may be a good idea!

Insulation testing can be performed by all meters I have found on the sale but many medical equipment manufacturers do not recommend the use of an insulation test as it is possible to damage them if they use transient suppressors. If you want a test to check the dielectric then use the IEC 62353 Alternative equipment leakage test in place of the insulation test.

After all you don't know if the DUT is fitted with transient suppressors!

Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 14,815
Likes: 72
Super Hero
Offline
Super Hero
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 14,815
Likes: 72

I think Robert's point was that in some areas you may find ancient (sub-standard) wiring, so it's unlikely that protection thereabouts would extend to RCD's (or, for that matter, MCB's).

Wire fuses in a distribution box, if you're lucky (and if you can find it). But even those won't help if the "earth" has been hanging by a thread by way of the metal (now iron oxide) conduit for twenty years! whistle

It seems to me that this whole "debate" is about the dumbing down of hitherto stringent testing standards (that have ensured electrical safety for many years - and was, as I have mentioned more than once before - one of the main reasons that "biomed" was established in the first place) simply to suit the "cleverness" (cheapness, "flimsiness"?) of some of the modern technology. And often non-medical technology, at that.

In short, the whole thing is a fudge! frown

In my opinion, it would be far better to get rid of all the unnecessary "gizmos". Medical equipment doesn't have to "talk to" each other directly (or to the laptop, the internet, the PDA, the toaster, or anything else). If some sort of connectivity is essential, then it can always be arranged via a proxy of some kind (eg, an intermediary device).

In other words, "get back to basics". The world becomes (returns to being) a safer place that way.

And lastly, as I have recently remarked to an Old Buddy of mine, (in regards to electrical safety, as with many other things) there is a world of difference between, shall we say, the pulse oximeter and the (again, for example) water bath! The Biomed has to recognise the nuances involved with each piece of kit, and act accordingly.


If you don't inspect ... don't expect.
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303
Likes: 17
MikeX Offline OP
Master
OP Offline
Master
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303
Likes: 17
Geoff, there is no dumbing down of standards involved!

The tests of IEC 62353 are as stringent as the tests carried out by most to 60601. Remember the device we are testing 'in service' has already passed the full range of 60601 tests before it ever came to market. 62353 simply takes that fact into account and modifies the testing to provide a quick and simple way to confirm all is still as it should be. There is no reduction of safety involved at all.

It is not reasonable to imply that somehow using 62353 will reduce the safety of any testing. But no matter what the standard used a certain amount of knowledge and experience is required to be able to perform any testing and analysis of the results and in fact this would be the weakest point in any testing, not the test standard used!

Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 14,815
Likes: 72
Super Hero
Offline
Super Hero
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 14,815
Likes: 72

Just to be clear, I am a supporter of the ideas behind 62353. That is, the adoption of an appropriate sub-set of 60601 for routine testing during maintenance.

As an aside I have been entering "IEC-62323" on job sheets recently against the box marked "Safety Standard used" (or whatever). And no-one has objected (or not even noticed, more like).

What you're saying is fair enough. But I think we can agree that any move towards dumbing-down is likely to result in standards slipping. I'm thinking more of prevailing attitudes, rather than Standards per se.

Thinking about it a bit more, I guess what I am not so sure about is the idea of "quick and easy". I prefer biomeds to have an awareness of what it is they are actually doing. As has been mentioned a few times before, there are many biomed shops where the workshop tester is left on "auto":- kit gets plugged in, the button gets pressed, and the tech returns (looking for the "passed" announcement) once the groans associated with "mains on applied parts" have subsided.

If I were in charge, I would hide the automatic tester from time to time and produce the Rigel 233 instead. Or, better yet (if I could find it) the CamSafe and Meggar, just to remind the young pups what electrical safety testing is actually all about.

As a historical (?) note, I have many times been in "needs must" situations myself where all I had was a multimeter, basic tools and a pair of eyes ... and yet was still able to satisfy myself that kit was safe. Also, in over 37 years worth of tests, I guess I have found perhaps less than twenty genuine "failures" at EST.

There have been dozens (hundreds?) of real failures, however, but these have almost always been apparent even without the need for any test instrument!

Thoughtful examination of the kit (mains plug, fuse(s), mains cable etc.) is the main "life saver" in my experience (but does little to sell electrical safety test instruments, unfortunately).

OK ... 200 mA is the minimum test current (for earth continuity) under 62353. So what is the maximum? Someone mentioned 8 Amps. frown


If you don't inspect ... don't expect.
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303
Likes: 17
MikeX Offline OP
Master
OP Offline
Master
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303
Likes: 17
Originally Posted By: Geoff Hannis

OK ... 200 mA is the minimum test current (for earth continuity) under 62353. So what is the maximum? Someone mentioned 8 Amps. frown


Currently no maximum test current is set by the standard. There is a routine review of IEC 62353 which has just started and some have put forward a suggested maximum value of 10A. We will see if this is accepted by the national committees in the fullness of time!

I agree that the automatic tests modes should be disabled from time to time to remind those conducting tests what they are actually doing! At least 62353 requires the comparison of test results which I know has not necessarily happened in the past.

Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 14,815
Likes: 72
Super Hero
Offline
Super Hero
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 14,815
Likes: 72

They state a minimum (of 200 mA), but fail to give a maximum? What sort of Standard is that? frown

I would suggest a maximum of 13 Amps (or so) thereby allowing 10 Amps to become available as the standard practice for those of us who believe in carrying out tests in accordance with the "traditional" approach.

"Requiring" a comparison of test results, and actually getting them compared are two completely different things, of course. But are we going back, then, to filling up computer files with reams of EST data? I'm asking that for two reasons:-

1) That idea has been roundly "kicked into touch" here (on the forum) before

... and ...

2) I'm wondering if I need to include provision for those records in my database

... so ...

... which results does 62353 require to be recorded, and compared?:-

1) All of them?
2) A sub-set only?
3) In any case, which ones are they?


If you don't inspect ... don't expect.
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303
Likes: 17
MikeX Offline OP
Master
OP Offline
Master
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 303
Likes: 17
Originally Posted By: Geoff Hannis

They state a minimum (of 200 mA), but fail to give a maximum? What sort of Standard is that? frown

A flexible one! Probably an oversight but since any testing is referenced back to IEC 60601 then the maximum can assumed to be 25A.

Originally Posted By: Geoff Hannis

I would suggest a maximum of 13 Amps (or so) thereby allowing 10 Amps to become available as the standard practice for those of us who believe in carrying out tests in accordance with the "traditional" approach.

The 10A limit would be to include a 10A test current as used by many current 60601 testers.

Originally Posted By: Geoff Hannis

"Requiring" a comparison of test results, and actually getting them compared are two completely different things, of course. But are we going back, then, to filling up computer files with reams of EST data? I'm asking that for two reasons:-

1) That idea has been roundly "kicked into touch" here (on the forum) before

... and ...

2) I'm wondering if I need to include provision for those records in my database

... so ...

... which results does 62353 require to be recorded, and compared?:-

1) All of them?
2) A sub-set only?
3) In any case, which ones are they?

Without comprehensive record keeping any litigation as a result of an incident would be difficult to defend without the data to back it up. A label stuck on a device saying it had passed a safety test may not stand up very well in court!

Without a comparison of test data, in particular leakage currents, it is not really acceptable to say a device is safe. Take an ultrasound probe, on previous tests it may have a leakage of 10uA but on the next test it has a leakage of 1500uA. Still within the 5000uA limit but obviously is failing. Are you happy for this to be classed as a pass?

The data to be stored is quite small and the actual data to be compared equally small (PE resistance, equipment leakage, applied part leakage BF & CF). Since any good software package will perform the comparison for you and alert if the values have changed significantly it is not all that onerous.

In countries such as Germany record keeping has been compulsory for more than 10 years now and I don't think they are sinking under a pile of data. smilewink Given data storage on a computer is very cheap now and automated testers have been with us for some time there really is no excuse for poor or non existent record keeping.

Page 3 of 5 1 2 3 4 5

Moderated by  DaveC in Oz, RoJo 

Link Copied to Clipboard
Who's Online Now
0 members (), 25,289 guests, and 104 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Newest Members
Pip Fox, Engzaki, MacMc, AraEmin, Edouardohaag
10,395 Registered Users
Forum Statistics
Forums26
Topics11,288
Posts74,594
Members10,395
Most Online69,877
Jul 17th, 2026
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5