Whoa guys!
There's obviously a lot of strongly held views here on both sides.
Talk about un-canning a tin of worms.....
I've presently got a sample of the Medgraphics battery sitting here on my bench which I intend to subject to a rigourous "caning". The Philips/Agilent spec is fairly clear about what the battery must be capable of, so let's find out if it meets the spec. I'll report my findings here.