John

You may recall a similar discussion re the MHRA gas regulators notice, I believe the same applies with manufacturers recommended PPM interval. My original comments were

"If you look at the notice under the Problem section it quotes that MHRA have received reports of leaks, inaccuracy and ignition from poorly maintained regulators or flowmeters. If a patient was to die from said device which was not properly maintained then the first thing the coroner would ask is if we followed the MHRA guidance as the risk was known.

I have spoken with MHRA at depth regarding previous notices and everything seems to be if we follow manufacturers advice then we would have nothing to worry about. Therefore if for example Therapy say just carryout functional test then that should satisfy any coroner or court. However this means that we would have to follow DO advice on two PPM a year.

The scenario would be if we were called to a coroners inquest to give evidence.

The coroner would ask "How frequently was the flowmeter serviced?"

If it was any less than what the manufacturer advices the Trust would be sued, remember that the family and possibly their lawyers would be at the inquest. What would stick in their mind is the Trust did not follow manufacturers APPROVED guidelines.

Food for thought!!! "

I had a chat with our legal advisor yesterday and he was horrified that a Trust would consider lengthening a manufacturers PPM interval. If an incident occurred and the patient complained the Trust would be legally liable to settle as the courts would latch on to the fact that we knowingling maintained a device below the spec required by the manufacturer. However he did say that we could stick to the manufacturers recommended PPM interval and heaven forbid if anything happened we could claim that we just didn't have the resources to perform the maintenance as agreed, which would be true.

What I am trying to say don't expose yourself John or your Trust by moving away from Manufacturers guidance, you can be sure if the S@#t hits the fan both the manufacturer and MHRA will drop you in it. Our legal advisers have discussed this in the past with MHRA and their stance is what ever the manufacturer says goes, the manufacturer has carried out the R & D and pre clinical testing to determine the service interval. MHRA and more importantly Trusts do not have access to this information to make a decision on PPM service intervals, we would not be able to defend our risk assessments in court. Can you safely say that you could John.

Just to add further doom and gloom, if a device malfunctioned and the patient died and the courts found out the service interval had been deliberatley increased. We have been advised that the individual who made that decision could theoretically be charged with manslaughter!!! This I feel puts it all into perspective

I hope this helps