John,You say
"have worked at, and visited many depts that over-maintain, or don't maintain. The reality is that both scenarios are wrong."
In your opinion they are wrong. Whos to say that you as and individual are right. The other depts may be in just the same mind as you. That is that they are right in what they do.
At the end of the day I know if something went wrong where I was involved I could stand up and say I did the maintenance to the standard that the manufacturer states in their documentation. If I didnt have the resources to do the work to that level I shouldnt have taken it on in the first place.