Quote:
So how does the manager scare senior management into providing more resources (read, funding), if the kit carries on working regardless? That is, as John has mentioned a few times before, and I myself must now grudgingly admit – kit is becoming more and more reliable (due, I dare say, to modern technology and thoughtful design – for the most part, anyway).
However, as John has quoted in postings elsewhere, the level of servicing required is related to usage in his opinion. I say it's also related to abuse but shouldn't be confused with equipment reliability. That's an additional extra that should be pushed onto the risk people. Given lots of usage over 5 years I doubt any device, particularly volumetric infusion pumps, to be operating to specification without exhibiting problems due to wear and tear or damage. I guess you were lucky that the machine had not been hammered Geoff. Generally I wouldn't classify a piece of equipment as being unreliable if it breaks down as a result of wear beyond the servicing interval - that would be an unfair assessment.

Reliability should only be judged on the rate of breakdowns due to random failures, design flaws or confirmed software issues that affect operation and cause device failures between the recommended service intervals in my opinion. Operator FOB problems, susceptibility to damage and abuse should be factored out of the assessment of reliability I think since these depend upon factors outside ours and the manufacturers control to some extent and should be flagged as seperate issues to risk people.

Perhaps the reason why they are never convinced is that we tend to roll these things into reliability instead of flagging them up seperately as operator issues and additional risk outside our control - we need the extra resources to cover this aspect by performing EST inspections to cover for this as required by HSE. These can be visual or visual and electrical but at least then the obvious problems are being spotted. It's severe damage due to user abuse and wear outside PPM that affects devices that are non-robust or not fit for purpose (irrespective of intrinsic device reliability assuming adequate servicing is being carried out as recommended) that goes unnoticed that presents the biggest risks if PPMs aren't carried out on a routine basis.

In the past I've seen syringe devices that have been literally split in half and still being used, taped-up, with no functioning occlusion alarms and ingress inside or others where the syringe actuator is broken and allows syringe-syphoning or where mains conductors are exposed that haven't been looked at for years and never been reported by users ignorant of the risks. Never really see this problem whenever I've worked on devices have been repaired or serviced within, say, a 12 month period (unless someones owned-up and sent it in for repair after it's been abused). Unfortunately it's the neglected items that slip through the net and aren't serviced at regular-enough intervals or not reported by operators as having damage (or inspecting the service-due labels) that are the biggest risk.