IEC 62353 only specifies a minimum earth bonding test current (>200mA either AC or DC) and leaves the choice up to the user. Most electricians have been using a 200mA DC test current for many years now and they have no problem with using this lower current.

In most cases a test instrument designed to conduct IEC 60601 tests can be either upgraded by software to conduct IEC 62353 tests or be adapted to conduct the direct method tests, by simple re-configuration of connections to the DUT.

As test equipment must inevitably be replaced it is prudent of any organisation to purchase new equipment that complies with the latest standards, particularly if those standards reduce test time and possibly increase safety.

A formal standard for testing medical equipment can only be a good thing as it removes the guesswork for those who may not have the experience of knowledge to decide what tests to select from the IEC 60601-1 type test standard.

I am not trying to encourage anyone to rush out and replace all their existing equipment with new IEC 62353 testers but there seems to be quite a few who do not want to even entertain the possibility that 62353 is the way forward and to investigate it properly and toughly.

I have seen too many Biomeds simply connect a device to a tester, press the button and wait for a pass/fail message. They do not look at the results to see if they happen to be close to the limit or even have increased since the last test and so may well miss an imminent failure. At least IEC 62353 formalises the need to compare previous values which must be a good thing?

Large EBME departments with many experienced engineers may become a thing of the past as time goes on and cutbacks prevail. It is essential to have a formal test standard that can be easily adopted by smaller groups and make enforcement by the HSE simpler than to try to have the current free-for-all situation.